Herbag Zip vs. Classic Herbag: Modular Style, Security, and Value

Check out our Hermès collection and Birkin bags!

The Hermès Herbag has quietly evolved from a discontinued design to one of the maison's most accessible and practical offerings.

What started as the original Herbag transformed in 2009 into the Herbag Zip, bringing enhanced security features and modern functionality to this Kelly inspired silhouette.

The main difference lies in closure systems and security: the classic Herbag features an open top design with strap closure, while the Herbag Zip offers zipper closure with additional security features like a back zip pocket and removable interior pouch.

Both versions keep the signature canvas and leather construction, making them an easy entry point into the Hermès world.

So, which one fits your lifestyle? If you care about easy access, the classic might suit you. If you need extra security, the Zip is probably more your speed. Either way, they're both more attainable than other Hermès icons.

Key Takeaways

• The Herbag Zip offers more security with zipper closure and extra pockets, while the classic sticks to an open top design.
• Both use the same canvas and leather, but their features and accessibility differ.
• Prices are similar, so it really comes down to whether you want convenience or more peace of mind.

Core Differences Between Herbag Zip and Classic Herbag

The original Herbag and its modern successor mainly differ in their closure systems, practical features, and production timeline, but both stick to the modular design that lets you swap bodies between canvas bases.

Design Evolution and Key Distinctions

The most noticeable difference is how these bags close and organize your stuff. The classic Herbag uses the old school flap closure with Hermès' Clou de Selle clasp.

You thread two leather straps through the metal clasp, a process some folks find a bit fiddly, others find charmingly classic. The original design keeps things straightforward with just one big compartment.

Hermès brought the bag back in 2009 with two big upgrades, creating the Herbag Zip. First, they added an external zip pocket on the back for quick access to essentials. Second, they tossed in a removable interior pouch for better organization. Suddenly, the bag went from a simple tote to a much more functional daily companion.

Despite these changes, the materials and silhouette stayed the same. Both have that familiar trapezoid shape inspired by the Kelly, with canvas bodies (Officier or Berline) and Hunter leather tops and handles.

Modular Body Switching and Mix and Match Features

Both versions share the clever detachable top system that collectors love. You can take off the leather flap and handles and swap in different canvas bodies.

One leather top can work with several canvas bases in different colors or patterns. Some vintage Herbags even came with two interchangeable bodies right from the boutique.

This modular system works the same on both versions. Leather parts attach to the canvas body in the same way, so you can mix and match to your heart's content.

Honestly, it's fun to create bicolour, tricolour, or even quadricolour looks by mixing different pieces. You can even turn some canvas bodies inside out for a more structured, minimalist look, a neat little hack.

Special editions like the Pegase Pop and H Vibration work with both classic and zip leather tops. The coated Berline canvas versions also bring extra durability and a bit of shine, pairing well with either closure style.

Naming, Release Timeline, and Discontinuation Facts

Naming wise, Hermès kept things simple at first: it was just the "Herbag" in the '80s and '90s, sometimes called the "Kelly Country" for its laid back Kelly vibe.

They discontinued the classic in the early 2000s. When it came back in 2009, it returned as the "Herbag Zip" to set it apart from the original.

You’ll see the Herbag Zip in sizes like 31, 39, and the larger travel friendly Herbag Zip Cabine 50 and 52.

The relaunch worked. The bag got a big boost after showing up in Hermès' Spring/Summer 2019 runway show. Unlike the original’s quiet run, the Herbag Zip has become a favorite among both new and seasoned Hermès fans.

If you’re after a vintage classic Herbag, you’ll have to hunt the resale market. The Herbag Zip, though, is still available as a non quota bag in Hermès boutiques.

Security Features and Closures

When it comes to security, the two Herbag models take pretty different approaches. The Classic Herbag sticks to traditional closure methods, while the Herbag Zip brings in modern zippered elements for extra protection.

Clou de Selle Closure Mechanism Explained

Both versions use Hermès' signature clou de selle closure system, a metal turnlock that secures the front flap.

You turn the metal piece clockwise to lock, counterclockwise to open. There's something undeniably satisfying about that little click.

It looks good and does the job, but let's be real: the clou de selle is more about style and tradition than serious security.

Zippered Pockets and Accessibility

The Herbag Zip stands out with its extra zippered features. Most notably, it has an external zip pocket on the front panel.

This pocket gives you fast access to things like keys or cards, so you don't have to dig into the main compartment every time.

Inside, the Herbag Zip includes a removable zippered pouch for organizing documents or personal items that need a bit more security.

The Classic Herbag, on the other hand, just has the main compartment and the clou de selle closure. It looks cleaner, but you lose out on modern organization.

Comparison of Locking Systems

The Classic Herbag’s closure keeps things elegant but not exactly secure. Its open top design makes it easy for you (and, unfortunately, others) to reach inside.

The Herbag Zip, with its extra closure points, offers more layers of security. The mix of traditional turnlock and modern zippers really hits that sweet spot between old school style and modern needs.

Honestly, if you’re in the city or just want more peace of mind, the Herbag Zip feels like the safer bet. The Classic Herbag is great when you’re prioritizing style.

Materials: Canvas and Leather Choices

Both Herbag versions use the same materials, canvas bodies paired with leather tops and metal accents. The combo of military canvas and Vache Hunter leather gives the bag its distinct personality.

Vache Hunter Leather: Texture and Durability

Both models use Vache Hunter cowhide for the top part, handles, and trim. This leather feels firm and structured, helping the bag keep its shape.

Let’s be honest: Vache Hunter scratches easily and shows wear pretty quickly. It’ll pick up scuffs from everyday use.

But that’s not all bad. Over time, the leather develops a patina and softens, giving your bag some real character. Some folks love how it ages.

At first, the leather is stiff and can make opening and closing the clasp a bit tricky. With use, it gets easier to handle.

Military Canvas and Other Canvas Variations

Military canvas is the go to material for most Herbag bodies. It’s tightly woven cotton, treated for durability and weather resistance.

This canvas is tough, resists tears, and keeps its shape well. It even handles moisture better than untreated fabrics.

Hermès sometimes uses Officier canvas too. Both types hold up about the same.

The canvas gives you tons of color and pattern options, sometimes even limited edition prints. That’s a level of customization you just can’t get with all leather bags.

Plus, canvas construction keeps these bags lighter than their all leather cousins, making both versions comfortable for longer use.

Hardware and Metal Accents

Both Herbag models use palladium or gold plated hardware, palladium is more common these days.

Signature touches include the Hermès lock, clochette, and the Clou de Selle closure. The metal hardware nods to the brand’s equestrian roots.

You can count on Hermès hardware to resist tarnishing and keep its finish. Clasps work smoothly and feel solid.

The lock mechanism is the same on both models, but only the Herbag Zip adds a zipper for extra security.

Style and Versatility

Both Herbag models shine when it comes to adapting to different styles and occasions. The modular canvas leather construction and flexible carry options make these bags surprisingly versatile for a luxury piece.

Mix and Match Modular Options

The real genius here is the detachable canvas bodies and leather frames. You can swap out different canvas colors and textures with the same leather base.

It’s like luxury Lego for grown ups who love Hermès.

Canvas bodies are totally removable and washable. That’s practical luxury, something you don’t always see at this price point.

Popular combos? Barenia leather with neutral canvas, or Epsom leather with seasonal prints. The mix keeps things interesting without screaming for attention.

Some collectors build an entire wardrobe around one leather frame. Is it cost effective? Well, as much as anything Hermès can be.

Herbag Zip Backpacks and Alternative Carry Styles

The Herbag Zip brought in a backpack style option that’s honestly a game changer. You can convert it from a handbag to a backpack with adjustable straps.

It takes just seconds, no special tools needed. The leather handles tuck away, and the shoulder straps extend for backpack mode.

Backpack mode is perfect for travel or busy days. It keeps the bag looking sophisticated but adds real world practicality.

Both models have detachable shoulder straps for crossbody wear, and the hardware is sturdy enough for daily switching.

Colourways and Limited Editions

Hermès drops new canvas patterns every season, sometimes with bold prints or special designs. These limited editions are catnip for collectors.

Recent years have seen geometric prints, nature themes, and abstract patterns. Canvas colors range from subtle to statement making.

Leather frames usually come in classic Hermès shades: Gold, Noir, Étoupe, Fauve. These neutrals go with almost any canvas you can imagine.

Limited edition collabs do pop up, though not as often as with the Kelly or Birkin. When they do, collectors snap them up fast.

Sizing Guide for Herbag Bags

The Herbag collection comes in a range of sizes, Zip and Classic versions each have their own options. Knowing the dimensions helps you pick the right bag for daily use or travel.

Herbag Zip Sizes: 31, 39, and Beyond

The Herbag Zip comes in three main sizes:

The 31cm size (31cm L x 25cm H x 10cm D) is great for everyday essentials. It fits your phone, wallet, keys, and some cosmetics without getting bulky.

The 39cm version (39cm L x 31cm H x 15cm D) gives you more room, think work or weekend outings when you need space for documents or a bit of shopping.

For travel, the Herbag Zip Cabine (52cm L x 36cm H x 20cm D) is huge. It can double as carry on luggage, but still looks unmistakably Hermès.

There’s also a Weekend version that’s somewhere in between, though the exact size can change from season to season.

Classic Herbag and Modern Cabine Bag Dimensions

The original Herbag used different sizing before the Zip took over.

Classic Herbags came in several sizes, including a Mini at 20cm length, perfect for minimalists who want Hermès quality in a tiny package.

The modern Cabine bag continues the travel friendly theme. It shares the 52cm length with the Zip Cabine, but the shape is a bit more relaxed.

Vintage Herbag sizes can vary a bit, so double check measurements if you’re buying pre owned. The modular canvas and leather construction helps the bag keep its shape, no matter the size.

Value, Resale, and Collectability

The Herbag lineup offers different value depending on what you’re after and your budget. Retail pricing is friendly compared to other Hermès bags, and the resale market tells an interesting story for both versions.

Herbag Zip vs. Classic Herbag Pricing

The Herbag Zip 31 goes for about $2,700 CAD at Hermès boutiques, while the bigger 39 clocks in around $2,900 CAD. For Hermès, these are about as approachable as it gets.

Classic Herbag prices jump all over the place on the resale market. Since Hermès stopped making them in the mid 2000s, you’re dealing with vintage, prices range from $730 to $3,682 CAD, depending on what shape they're in and how rare they are.

If you want a fresh from the store Herbag Zip, be ready to pay up. On resale sites, pristine ones go for $3,900 to $4,100 CAD, about a grand over retail.

Both versions let you swap out canvas bodies, so you can kind of build your own setup. Buying extra pieces gives you more looks, without buying a whole new bag.

Comparison with Hermès Kelly Bag

Let’s not kid ourselves. The Herbag lives in a totally different price universe than the Kelly. Kelly bags start at $10,000 CAD and only go up from there, while Herbags keep the same chic silhouette without that jaw dropping sticker shock.

Mixing canvas and leather keeps Herbag prices in check, but you still get the Hermès vibe. People sometimes call the original Herbag "Kelly Country," which nails its laid back but still polished feel.

Kelly bags usually hold or even gain value over time. Herbags? Not so much. They follow more typical depreciation, except for the occasional rare edition that bucks the trend.

Accessibility and Investment Potential

Both Herbag types are way more accessible than most Hermès bags. You won’t have to jump through hoops or wait forever, unlike with Birkins or Kellys.

Because Hermès keeps making the Herbag Zip, you can actually find one without drama. Limited editions like the Pegase Pop or H Vibration have a bit more collector buzz, but most are easy enough to track down.

Classic Herbags have picked up some collector interest just because they're scarce now. Vintage Hermès fans like them, but don’t expect Kelly level returns.

If you want practical luxury, either Herbag gives you solid cost per wear. They’re casual, tough, and work for all sorts of days.

Frequently Asked Questions

Security, modularity, and value are big factors when picking between these two Hermès staples. Size and travel needs matter too, depending on your lifestyle.

What's the real lowdown on security features between the Herbag Zip and the Classic Herbag?

The Herbag Zip doesn’t mess around, it’s got a zipper closure, so your stuff stays put. That’s a step up from the Classic’s more open design.

You’ll find a zipped back pocket on the Zip version, plus a removable zipped pouch inside for valuables. Handy for keeping things organized.

The Classic Herbag uses a Kelly style lock, which is undeniably elegant, but it doesn’t lock things down quite as tightly as the Zip’s setup.

Is there a noticeable difference in practical day to day modularity between the Herbag Zip and its Classic counterpart?

The Herbag Zip wins out here, thanks to its removable pouch. You can switch up the inside depending on what you need that day.

Both bags have the classic canvas/leather combo, but the Zip throws in extra pockets, making it easier to keep things sorted.

The Classic is a bit more laid back and open, so it’s easier to grab things quickly, but you lose some of that internal organization.

Speaking value for money, how does the Herbag Zip square up against the timeless Classic Herbag?

The Herbag Zip’s extra features bump up the price, expect around $2,250 CAD for the 31cm, while vintage Classics can go for less.

Those extra pockets and the removable pouch really do add value, especially if you’re into organization and security.

Older Classic Herbags might be cheaper, but finding one in great shape isn’t always easy. You’ll need some patience (and luck) hunting the pre loved market.

How do the sizes available for the Herbag collection, like the mini and the 50, impact your luxury lifestyle?

The Herbag Zip 31 is kind of the sweet spot for daily use. At 31cm x 25cm x 10cm, it holds your phone, wallet, and the basics.

The 39cm works if you need to carry a laptop or work stuff. At 39cm x 31cm x 15cm, it bridges everyday and work life nicely.

Then there’s the Cabine at 52cm, now you’re talking travel bag. It’s big enough for a weekend but still looks sharp.

Does the Herbag Zip's cabin bag size make it the ultimate travel buddy or is the Herbag 31 still the go to for jet setters?

The Herbag Zip Cabine (52cm) is awesome for weekend trips or short getaways. You can fit a couple of outfits and the essentials without lugging around a monster bag.

The 31cm is better if you’re flying a lot and need something that slips under the seat and still looks classy at the airport.

It really comes down to how you travel. If you’re more about quick escapes, go Cabine. If you want easy, stylish carry on, the 31’s probably your pick.

When it comes to turning heads at the next soirée, which Herbag version should you clutch for that effortlessly chic vibe?

The Classic Herbag gives off that relaxed Parisian elegance we all kind of wish we could master. Its softer shape and easygoing design just feel naturally sophisticated, almost like you didn’t even try.

On the other hand, the Herbag Zip leans into structure and polish. Those sharper lines and the secure closure? They scream modern luxury, but in a way that’s actually practical for real life.

Both versions stick to that Kelly inspired silhouette everyone seems to notice. So, do you lean vintage with a hint of mystery, or do you go crisp and contemporary? Honestly, it’s a tough call.